The world of fish is not a silent one. Fish make sounds and hear each other, just like we do.
And for decades now, scientists have been eavesdropping on them using underwater microphones. But the documentation of freshwater fish lags far behind marine species.
“On the one hand, there's sort of like the despondent approach of saying, ‘The Great Lakes are so cool and so important. It's really a bummer they don't get the attention they deserve,’” said Aaron Rice, a marine biologist at Cornell University.
“On the other hand, there's sort of the optimistic perspective saying, ‘Look, right in our backyard, there's still the opportunity for basic discovery in science that nobody's ever looked at or listened to.’”
Now, a researcher from Chicago is exploring a new underwater frontier: recording the sounds of some of the Great Lakes’ most overlooked bottom feeders — suckers.
Credits:
Host/Executive Producer: Dan Wanschura
Editor: Morgan Springer
Senior Producer: Ellie Katz
Additional Editing: Austin Rowlader, Peter Payette
Music: Blue Dot Sessions, Matthew C. Wright
Archival Audio and Fish Sounds: United States Navy; Cornell Lab Macaulay Library; R. Rountree, M. Coen, I.T. Jones, E. Lindsay, J.C. Bowman, B.E. Howell via FishSounds, K.M. Stafford at the University of Washington via Discovery of Sound in the Sea, Shedd Aquarium
Sonic ID: Nic M. Neves
Episode Art: Mikayla Kerba
Transcript:
DAN WANSCHURA, HOST: Welcome to Points North. I’m Dan Wanschura. The world of fish is not a silent one. Fish make sounds and hear each other, just like we do. And for decades now, scientists have been eavesdropping on them using underwater microphones.
ARCHIVAL: Time is 5:30, June 2nd, June 3rd.
AARON RICE: It's sort of magical because you can't really see what's going on.
ARCHIVAL: 4 September 1964, 8:05 PM.
RICE: In some cases you can, a lot of times you can't.
ARCHIVAL: Recording of Semotilus margariscus, April 17th, 1960, 9:50 AM.
ARCHIVAL: There is no moon out. The sun is down.
RICE: So you got your headphones on.
ARCHIVAL: There's a considerable amount of static or loud noise coming over the tape recorder.
RICE: You hear the splash of it going in.
ARCHIVAL: Lots of background noise
RICE: And then you're trying to orient yourself.
ARCHIVAL: There are lights from the overhead light on Naut Lab and from the ship.
RICE: And then it's almost like somebody flips a switch.
ARCHIVAL: Okay.
ARCHIVAL: I will commence recording now.
ARCHIVAL: Okay.
[archival hydrophone plunging into water]
[underwater sounds of American eel, fathead minnow, freshwater drum, northern leopard frog, white sucker, brook trout, pumpkinseed]
RICE: And you are hearing this completely foreign world that's like just right beneath you, but you can't see anything. And the way sound travels underwater, you can hear literally across like miles. You will hear fish both big and small. Maybe you'll hear crayfish or other invertebrates. Like the whole thing just sort of, you know, I would say comes to life, but the reality is it's already alive. It's just that as humans, we're actually sort of keying into it.
ARCHIVAL: 8:32 PM, uh, recording is, uh, ended. Much of the background noise was due to a bunch of fishermen and, uh, various other individuals roaming throughout the area.
[archival U.S. Navy music]
RICE: I'm Aaron Rice. I'm a marine biologist at Cornell University. The invention of the hydrophone, or an underwater microphone, was initially developed in the 20s and 30s, then used in World War II for listening for enemy submarines.
U.S. NAVY RECORDING: Once under the surface and below periscope depth, your only contact with friendly or enemy ships is by means of sound. Listen to the sound of a destroyer as heard with this new JP-1 Sonic listening gear.
RICE: The Navy and folks around the world started getting all these weird sounds on hydrophones, and they're like, "The heck is this? Are these, like, animals? Like they're not subs, and they're not ships. What the heck's going on down there?”
U.S. NAVY: You must learn to recognize underwater sounds. Even fish make noises, though you may never have heard them.
RICE: “This was deemed as a national security concern until we found out it was a fish, or a snapping shrimp, or whatever.”
U.S. NAVY: Croakers make this sort of sound, and porpoise sound like this. But a tin fish sounds like this. Enemy ships will be music to your ears and sound just as natural when you hear them on your topside sonic listening gear.
[archival U.S. Navy music]
RICE: The irony is that the rest of the world has been listening to fish and whales calling underwater literally for millennia.
The first written accounts in the Western scientific or natural history literature of fish making sounds is Aristotle.
Indigenous communities around the world have been listening to fish underwater, either through free diving or through the hull of boats. Tribes in Alaska and the Canadian Arctic would actually, in their canoes or their kayaks, would take an oar and put one end underwater and put the handle up against their jaw, and they could feel the vibration of bowhead whales singing.
[sound of bowhead whale song]
RICE: Fishes as a taxonomic group have been referred to as “the lower vertebrates” because they're not thought to be as magical or interesting as mammals or birds or other critters.
ARCHIVAL: There are now seven males in the tank and four females.
RICE: It's this funny contradiction because I talk to fish biologists, people that have spent their lives and careers studying fish, and I'm like, “Yeah, I study fish sounds,” and they'll say, “You know, I never really thought about that.”
ARCHIVAL: Handheld sounds from the channel catfish. The fish was approximately 14 inches in length, and was held about three inches from the hydrophone.
[SFX]
RICE: Fish are so cool because they do everything. Like fish, they fly, they eat anything underwater. They live in nearly all aquatic environments around the world.
ARCHIVAL: We will now place the microphone under the pan once more, where there's still a great deal of activity going on.
RICE: The idea of recording in marine systems is more common, but for some reason, freshwater systems are largely ignored, and the documentation of freshwater sounds is woefully behind. And so, like on the one hand, there's sort of like the despondent approach of saying, you know, the Great Lakes are so cool and so important. It's really a bummer they don't get the attention they deserve. And on the other hand, there's sort of the optimistic perspective saying, look, right in our backyard. There's still the opportunity for basic discovery in science that nobody's ever looked at or listened to.
WANSCHURA: After the break, one person listening to fish in the Great Lakes.
KAREN MURCHIE: If we can't see them, can we hear them?
[sound of stream]
KAREN MURCHIE: So most of the time, if I start talking about animal migrations, I'm like, "Put up your hand if you can name like an animal that migrates." And people will be like, "Monarch, butterflies, wildebeest," right?
Wildebeest are something that probably everybody has seen on some nature show at some point. They're amazing migrations, and because they're land animals, you can see them in their large numbers on the Serengeti, moving in these incredible migrations.
[sound of pounding hooves]
If you can take that from the land, put it underwater, but then change, you know, wildebeest into fish form, this is what we're talking about with suckers.
MURCHIE: They're a group of non-game fish, meaning that they're not sport fish, not ones that people tend to angle for.
And in the spring, all over the Great Lakes, they're moving in large numbers. This is going on beneath the surface, and most people don't pay attention to it.
I'm Karen Murchie, and I'm the director of freshwater research at Shedd Aquarium in Chicago, and I also run our migratory fishes program, which is focused on suckers in the Great Lakes.
Being our most abundant group of migratory fish in the Great Lakes, we know very little about them.
MURCHIE: I've got volunteers across Illinois, Wisconsin, and Michigan on both sides of the lake, peeking in the creeks in the spring to document the sucker spawning migrations.
One of the biggest challenges is that when you would get the snow melt, or if there was rain, it would make the water kind of look like chocolate milk.
Yeah, that's when I started to think about, “Could we use sound and listening for the spawning sounds that the suckers make to know that they're there?”
AARON RICE: When she started expressing an interest in sound. I was pretty excited, but you know, at the same time, like I have this unique perspective where my go-to reaction is like, "Yeah, of course they make sounds. That would be super cool. Nobody's done it. We should totally do that." So I sent her my hydrophone. I sent her a recorder, and I'm like, "Man, I hope this works."
MURCHIE: It’s like a- it's sort of like its own underwater symphony. I was there at that concert for that one moment in time that will never ever happen again.
[sound of sucker spawning]
MURCHIE: Sounds kind of like a rain stick, where it starts kind of slow and then it builds up and then it trails back down. Most often, it's two or three males around one female, and they're all. Vibrating vigorously, their tails are just going so fast and they're moving the sand and gravel. There were multiple spawning sounds. You could start to hear one in the foreground, closest to the mic, really loud, but also at the same time, in the distance, you can also hear more spawning sounds. Or sometimes too, then all of a sudden, you could hear an individual fish had come up, and they were like, you know, making this sort of like a sucking sound. I'm like, are they actually sucking on the microphone? Like I can hear this noise. This is a soundtrack that non-human animals make.
RICE: It's more than just sort of a random rock splashing or, you know, something rolling. It's clearly deliberate behavior. You know, you're starting to contextualize the environment in which these fish live.
If you put it in this human context, it's completely obvious, right? Like this is what we do on a day-to-day basis, whether it's in the workplace or at home, or we're going shopping.
Let's say you know you close your eyes. You could hear human conversation, but then if you were in some place that's like a long hallway, and you have somebody that's like walking down the hall, like in high heels. You'll hear the clicking of the shoes on the floor. You can get an idea: is this a big space or is this a little space? Am I hearing echoes? Is this person running fast? Are they walking slowly? Are there two people that are there? Animals do the same thing, and so we can get an idea from sounds that they are producing, either intentionally or unintentionally, you know, other insights about what they're doing and how they're- and how they're behaving just through this perspective of sound.
We want to figure out, “How does this incredible place work? How does it do its thing?” And sound is a way to do that.
ARCHIVAL: 4 September 1964.
ARCHIVAL: The correct date on this recording is April 19, 1960.
ARCHIVAL: Uh, there is no moon out. The sun is down.
ARCHIVAL: Placed the hydrophone in the small stream.
ARCHIVAL: Okay.
ARCHIVAL: I will commence recording now.
[archival hydrophone plunge]
[hydrophone recording of water]
ARCHIVAL: End recording.
WANSCHURA: That story from senior producer Ellie Katz.
WANSCHURA: Scientists have already learned things about fish using hydrophones. Like when they recorded round gobies, a really aggressive invasive species in the Great Lakes, they realized these fish make grunting and drumming sounds. And then they realized they could play recordings of mating sounds back to the gobies, and lure them into traps. It worked. Or with invasive carp — biologists have figured out these fish can hear lower frequencies than many other fish. And they don’t like them. So playing it low and loud underwater can help stop them from getting into the Great Lakes.