He Was Wrongly Convicted When They Were Teens. Now They're Building Their Lives Together

Jul 20, 2018
Originally published on July 20, 2018 12:13 pm

In the summer of 1994, in Tulsa, Okla., Brandy Carpenter, then 14, had just started dating her crush, 17-year-old De'Marchoe Carpenter.

But before they even had their first kiss, De'Marchoe was arrested for a murder he didn't commit.

At StoryCorps in May, De'Marchoe, 41, and Brandy, 38, remember what first drew them to each other, and the toll that prison took on their relationship.

"You always made me laugh and you always made me smile," Brandy says. "I always wanted you to be around."

They simply enjoyed each other's company. "We just hung out, sitting on the porch, talking," De'Marchoe says. "It was your eyes that allured me to you. They just dance. It seemed like we got close — and then I was arrested."

Brandy was confident in De'Marchoe's innocence. "I had no doubt that you would be coming home," she says. "I knew it was just a big misunderstanding."

De'Marchoe remembers Brandy showing up to his court date when he was to learn his verdict — that he'd been found guilty of first-degree murder and sentenced to life plus 170 years in prison.

"I held my head up high, you know, I tried to maintain my composure," he says. "When I got back to my cell, you know, I put my head under my covers and I just cried. I remember I cried myself to sleep."

"I knew that they got it wrong," Brandy says. "They got it all wrong."

But then they lost contact. "I was writing letters and I felt like you stopped writing me," De'Marchoe says.

"And I felt like you stopped writing me," Brandy says. "But I think we figured out it was my mom not letting me know that I had those letters."

"It was 13 and a half years later when you came back into my life," De'Marchoe tells her. They reconnected through De'Marchoe's brother, who had given him Brandy's phone number at her request. They started talking regularly by phone, and then she applied successfully to be added to his visitors list.

"For the last six years of my incarceration, you know, you was there for me," he says. "You came to visit me every week."

"I remember coming in, having to take everything off — my earrings, my belt, my bracelets. I used to pray for this: 'I just wanna be able to hug him,' " Brandy says. "Now it's like, I can't sleep without you."

In 2016, 13 days after De'Marchoe was released from prison, Brandy and De'Marchoe Carpenter got married.

But he has to cope daily with anxiety caused by being in prison.

"I worry about you," Brandy says.

"Prison, it messed me up," he says. "To see someone getting stabbed and, you know, to be confined to a cell 23 hours a day, sometimes six months at a time when we're on lockdown, it had an effect on me in a terrible way."

"I don't believe people realize how bad your anxiety is," Brandy says. "They don't see the breakdowns, the meltdowns."

She recalls one early morning during his first days home. "I get up, and I look outside, I see you pulling out of the driveway in the truck," Brandy says.

De'Marchoe says he can feel an urge to spend time alone. "Sometimes I just wanna get up and leave — just because," he says. "And, you know, not have to worry about 'Where you goin'? What you doin'?' For me, it's like, for 17 years my mom told me what to do. For 22 years, prison officials told me what to do. I've never had the time where I called the shots for myself."

As for Brandy, she hopes their communication only gets stronger. "I just wish that you would let me know what's going through your mind so I can know how to help," she says. "But we've been through things worse than this — the visits, waiting on you to come home. If we can get through those things, we can get through these things."

Produced for Morning Edition by Aisha Turner.

StoryCorps is a national nonprofit that gives people the chance to interview friends and loved ones about their lives. These conversations are archived at the American Folklife Center at the Library of Congress, allowing participants to leave a legacy for future generations. Learn more, including how to interview someone in your life, at StoryCorps.org.

Copyright 2018 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

DAVID GREENE, HOST:

And it's time for StoryCorps. It was the summer of 1994, and Brandy Guest (ph) was 14 years old. She had just started dating her crush, 17-year-old De'Marchoe Carpenter. But before they had their first kiss, De'Marchoe was arrested for a murder he did not commit in Tulsa, Okla. He was exonerated 22 years later. At StoryCorps, he and Brandy remembered what first drew them to each other.

BRANDY CARPENTER: You always made me laugh. And you always made me smile. I always wanted you to be around.

DE'MARCHOE CARPENTER: We just hung out, sitting on the porch talking. It was your eyes that allured me to you. They just danced. It seemed like we got close. And then I was arrested.

B. CARPENTER: I had no doubt that you would be coming home. I knew it was just a big misunderstanding.

D. CARPENTER: I got found guilty for murder. I end up receiving a life sentence, plus 170 years. And I remember you being at my court date. And I held my head up high. You know, I tried to maintain my composure. But when I got back to my cell, I put my head under my covers, and I just cried. I remember I cried myself to sleep.

B. CARPENTER: I knew that they got it wrong. They got it all wrong.

D. CARPENTER: We lost contact, you know. And I was writing letters. And I felt like you stopped writing me.

B. CARPENTER: And I felt like you stopped writing me. But I think we figured out it was my mom not letting me know that I had those letters.

D. CARPENTER: It was 13 and a half years later when you came back into my life. For the last six years of my incarceration, you know, you was there for me. You came to visit me every week.

B. CARPENTER: I remember coming in, having to take everything off - my earrings, my belt, my bracelets. I used to pray for this. I just wanted to be able to hug him. Now, it's like I can't sleep without you. But I worry about you.

D. CARPENTER: Prison, it messed me up. To see someone getting stabbed and, you know, to be confined to a cell 23 hours a day, sometimes six months at a time when we're on lockdown, it had an effect on me in a terrible way.

B. CARPENTER: I don't believe people realize how bad your anxiety is. They don't see the breakdowns, the meltdowns. I mean, when you first got out, I woke up and you aren't in the bed. So I get up, and I look outside. And I see you pulling out of the driveway in a truck.

D. CARPENTER: Sometimes I just want to get up and leave just because and, you know, not have to worry about - where are you going, or what are you doing? For me, it's like for 17 years my mom told me what to do. For 22 years, prison officials told me what to do. I've never had a time where I called the shots for myself.

B. CARPENTER: I just wish that you would let me know what's going through your mind so I could know how to help. But we've been through things worse than this - the visits, waiting on you to come home. If we can get through those things, we can get through these things.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

GREENE: Brandy and De'Marchoe Carpenter for StoryCorps.

They got married two years ago, 13 days after De'Marchoe was released from prison. Their full interview will be archived at the Library of Congress. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.